SearchSimple Shepherd's Piemonet6784 08th May 2006
10 comments
Comment from: Elise Bauer [Visitor] · http://www.elise.com/recipes
Hey there! Please do NOT copy recipes directly from my website. The descriptions and the photos are protected by US Copyright laws. They are not for public distribution.
22nd May 2006 @ 04:15
Comment from: Alanna [Visitor] · http://kitchen-parade-veggieventure.blogspot.com/
Hey! Don't you know it's bad manners, bad business and plain old BAD to steal content? That makes you a THIEF.
22nd May 2006 @ 17:23
Comment from: kalyn [Visitor] · http://kalynskitchen.blogspot.com
I can assure, Elise is not the only one who would object to having a recipe copied directly from her site and posted somewhere else. Not only is this extremely poor behavior on your part, but your "apology" is rude and mean-spirited. It's not about whether it's strictly legal or not, it's about honor between fellow bloggers. This seems like a poor way to attract people to your site. I know that I personally wouldn't visit a site that treated a fellow blogger with such disdain.
22nd May 2006 @ 18:09
Comment from: Elise Bauer [Visitor] · http://www.elise.com/recipes
Actually, you are welcome to this recipe - the ingredients and instructions, which I share freely with any and all, just not to the introductory description - my words, or the photos - my photos. Regarding the note that you aren't doing this for money, that's actually besides the point. But now that you mention it, it appears that Big Blog Media is a commercial venture, supported to some degree by revenue from Google Adsense, is that not so?
My request is that you remove the introductory paragraph and the photos.
22nd May 2006 @ 18:46
Comment from: elymiles [Member]
Ladies, please.
I wish to offend nobody. I merely enjoy food. I was irritated by the narrow-mindedness of the initial attack. Yes, I used her recipe. I'd tried it and enjoyed it, so I posted it to share with others. I was also courteous enough to credit the author - something many would not do and something that is engineered to direct traffic to the source - ie: if you like this, there's lots more good stuff on "Simply Recipes" But really, when all is said and done, does it really matter - its a Shepherd's pie, something that I, my mother and my grandmother can cook in our sleep - as can all of you. It hardly constitutes identity theft. Kalyn - the lady concerned is not a 'fellow blogger' - a blogger like myself wouldn't mind. The reason she's 'offended' is because she's involved in a commercial venture and objects to the inherent freedom of blogs to provide links and information. Had I not said where the information came from and claimed it as my own, you would obviously have a point. I didn't, I credited the source and she benefitted from a series of track-backs - that's how she know. Had I merely stolen the information, with atributing the proper credit, she wouldn't have had a clue that I'd used her recipe. As for Big Blog Media - its the company that owns the site, they've merely given me a vehicle on which to post
22nd May 2006 @ 19:25
Comment from: Don M [Visitor] · http://www.thisblogthing.com
I don't believe Elise is having a hissy fit and that she is perfectly allowed to complain publicly. What you are doing is the same as ripping a band's music CD and then posting all the MP3's from that CD on the web. The band would complain that you are taking their effort to monetize their work and made it freely available to everyone. Sure, you could say that you are just "passionate about music" and the "band is apparently trying to make money off it" - but isn't that a little off base?
Using her pictures and using her own introductory paragraph is plain laziness. If it is a recipe you really liked yourself (like you stated in your "excuse" at the end) then you should have put your "excuse" at the beginning originally instead of after Elise called you on it. This kind of behavior bothers me when someone is free to do what they please with someone else's work and then make that someone else (Elise) look like the BAD person for speaking up. I have family members that do this and it is nothing short of irritating. Even in your faux-apology you sound very condescending.
24th May 2006 @ 02:20
Comment from: Don M [Visitor] · http://www.thisblogthing.com
I might also add upon further reading that to say this site is not meant to provide revenue is one of the most blatant falsehoods I have ever heard. The introductory paragraph on the page is very obviously crafted for search engine optimization, and the AdSense on the right are - what - there for decorative purposes?
Regardless, I am sure BigBlogMedia is loving all the controversy. I imagine this is why the copyrighted photos have not been removed yet. Anyways, I gotta run. I just borrowed my friends new Red Hot Chili Peppers CD and I'm gonna post all the MP3s of the songs on my music site. To use your quote, "I do this because I enjoy food (in my case ... music) and feel that its worthwhile sharing that enjoyment". Free Chili Peppers everybody!
24th May 2006 @ 02:37
Comment from: ed adkins [Visitor] · http://edadkins.com
i think the comment "a blogger like myself wouldn't mind" is pretty laughable- most bloggers would be pissed at someone who cut and pasted their post and pics like that- regardless of whether you posted where you got it from.
it's probably best you just link to her post.
26th May 2006 @ 07:35
Comment from: Chris [Visitor] · http://mpa.org
Thought this was about music but turns out its a about a pie, but ok: Don your argument is flawed,ripping a cd and posting to the web, is changing the content distribution model, rather like this blogger, taking the recipe, and then publishing it in a book. To use your Chili Peppers Analogy you don't need to rip the cd, simply lending it a friend is the same, you ever lent a book or a cd to anyone?.You can't compare music to a blog post. For what is worth on the argument. The best link any site can get these days is from a link from within an article, seems to me everyone has got out of their pram on this one. A further credit on the images should probably have been the solution. In a web 2.0 world everything is about aggregation, the more sites you can get your content on the better ( so long as you are credited for it ) I think you all to kiss and make up.
26th May 2006 @ 14:19
Comment from: Danielle [Visitor] · http://www.celebrity-babies.com
You really don't have a leg to stand on. What you have done is, legally, copyright infringment, and ethically, a really lame thing to do. You make it even worse by taunting her. That's just mean. I am sure that if you were in Elise's shoes, you would feel exactly the same way she does.
-A "fellow blogger" (2 1/2 years and counting)
03rd July 2006 @ 03:39
Leave a comment |
|
||||